Managing By
"What If"
What if you knew the future in making decisions?
During a conversation with a
distributor, this writer asked these questions regarding inventory
and dating. "Does your sales force often face a situation
where a garden center has placed his large seasonal order with
a deferred payment schedule, and when the first payment is due,
the check doesn't arrive? Yet when your sales representative makes
their usual sales call on the garden center, the representative
finds that the owner of the business has a repaved parking lot,
a new roof, or perhaps a new automobile?"
The answer that
the distributor gave was, "It happens more times than you
would think."
This does not at all infer that
there was an intent to deceive on behalf of the business. It merely
confirms that many retailers have not had the opportunity to be
exposed to the theory of cash management planning for their business.
In the early 1980's, as computers were beginning to make their way
into retail operations, one of the features that was highly touted
was the "what if" capability of the computer software.
The software was designed so
that a business could take their profit and loss statement and begin
to examine the interrelation effect of increased sales or inventory,
increased margins, deferred billing of inventory purchased, purchase
of equipment, changes in expenses, or any other figure on the statements.
As this feature was developed, the idea was that you would also
see the change of cash on hand from your balance sheet.
If the software
had an elaborate formula, you would be able to examine these changes,
and their effects for each of the next twelve accounting periods.
As we have heard from this distributor,
and seen in many other situations, the accountants, vendors, and
associations have somehow been unable to convince many retailers
of the value of the "what
if" tool, and the technique necessary to develop it. Yet
as one banker stated, "When I asked the retailer that had
just applied for a loan, how soon he would want the funds, he
responded, 'how about tomorrow?'"
So, why should a garden
center want a cash flow chart, and what is involved in building
one? The answer to the first question is not just to prevent the
situations that was described already. Perhaps the best reason
would be to tell you that a retailer utilizing a cash flow chart
could accurately forecast his cash balance, inventory, open to
buy, and accounts receivable, for each of the next 12 months.
And as the chart was updated, it would become more and more accurate.
The banker that made the previous
comments stated that he would be very impressed with the retailer
that could come into his office and tell him that he was going to
have a cash shortage three months from now, and then demonstrate
how he would be able to pay the money back using the cash flow chart.
The building of a cash flow
chart requires data from your balance sheet and your profit and
loss statement. From the balance sheet, we will need to have the
inventory, accounts receivable balance, and the cash on hand. We
will also utilize the figures that appear on the profit and loss
statement.
You will have the option of
building a chart that takes into account all of your accrual items.
These are the expenses and incomes that are recognized on your financial
sheet at a time other than when they are actually received or paid.
Some of these examples would be property taxes, dividends from a
cooperative, income tax, and rent overrides paid to a landlord.
If your profit and loss statement
is not using the accrual method, you probably will not want to have
a cash flow chart that is utilizing the accrual method.
The other
option is the cash method. Each item is documented when it is actually
paid. This is much simpler but you will probably have some extremely
profitable months and some extremely unprofitable months.
To begin
constructing the chart, start with your cash on hand and add to
that your incomes. If your cash flow chart lists your gross sales,
and all of your expenses, you can better use the chart for the "what
if" scenario
to see the effect of changes in each of these items.
By also
entering the change in inventory, accounts receivable, sales,
and accounts payable, you will begin to see which months will
have a buildup of cash, and which months will have cash deficits
in the coming 12 months. Using each of your past 12 financial
statements, you will have excellent material on which to create
your projects. And as you have completed each month, you can extend
your cash flow chart for another month, as well as see a clearer
picture of the months in the near future.
While you can create
this material using a calculator, you can imagine how easy this
will be if you are using a computer software program such as Microsoft
Excel. By creating such a chart in a template spread sheet,
you will be able to see in just a moment what the effect would be
of increasing your overall margin by 1/2%, or by eliminating
an unnecessary expense.
Most people have a tendency
to either be a historian or a visionary when looking at the financial
information of their store. The proper place is to show tendencies
from both directions. Your balance sheet and the profit and loss
sheet provide your historical look. Here, with your cash flow chart,
is your vision to the future.